Ductile Pipe vs Steel Pipe (Galvanized & Carbon): Strength, Durability & Cost Compared
There are many types of pipeline materials you can pick for your project, whether it’s municipal water supply, sewage, fire protection, or industrial infrastructure. Ductile iron pipes and steel pipes are probably two of the most well-known materials, and they often leave you unsure which one to choose. The fact is, selecting the right material can decide whether your project succeeds or fails. That’s why we’ve compared ductile iron pipes and steel pipes in full.
Yasmin Trading, the leading ductile iron pipe supplier in the UAE and the GCC region, wants to provide you with the right solution. In this comprehensive guide, we will cover strength, durability, corrosion resistance, hydraulic flow, installation, lifecycle cost, and more for both pipes, so you can stay on the right side and make the best decision.
What Are Ductile Iron Pipes?
Ductile iron is cast iron with an enhanced level of strength, durability, and reliability compared to regular cast iron. The features are due to the magnesium added during the manufacturing process. Magnesium turns the carbon into tiny round balls called spherical graphite nodules. The basic makeup is mostly iron, with 3.0–3.9% carbon and a small amount of magnesium (source: ScienceDirect).
They usually have special coatings on the outside (such as bitumen, epoxy, or polyethylene sleeves) to protect them from soil and moisture. Inside, they have a smooth cement-mortar lining that stops rust and helps water flow more easily.
Standards They Meet: Ductile Iron Pipes are designed to match the strictest global standards, such as ISO 2531, EN 545, and AWWA C151.
Advantages of Using Ductile Iron
- Easy Installation: Ductile iron pipes have proven to be easy to install. These pipes can be installed with a variety of joints. The easy installation process of ductile iron pipes is why they are widely used to fit various applications.
- Strength and Durability: Ductile iron has an improved level of strength. Pipes that are made of ductile iron are commonly long-lasting and have the ability to withstand high pressure.
- Cost-effective: Ductile iron pipes generally offer the required performance with much lower initial costs. Other types of piping, such as copper or steel, will do the job at a higher expense.
- Corrosion Resistance: Due to some microstructural features, ductile iron pipes show good corrosion resistance. This helps them maintain a desirable performance for a long time.
Common Applications for Ductile Iron
Engineers and contractors go for the ductile iron pipe for the tough conditions, especially when the pressure is very high. You can mostly see these pipes in wastewater systems and water supply. Ductile Iron pipe offers many advantages, and that’s why it is also useful for various cases, including:
- Gas Distribution: Ductile iron pipes are widely used in gas distribution networks. This is because of their high strength in such conditions. Also, being resistant to corrosion is a key factor for this application.
- Industrial Applications: Ductile iron pipes are widely used in industrial settings. Their strength in high-pressure environments allows them to transport fluids.
- Water and Sewage Systems: When it comes to water and wastewater systems, the main critical feature the piping must have is corrosion resistance. Ductile iron pipes are fairly resistant to corrosion and have a high level of durability and strength.
- Fire Protection Systems: Ductile iron pipes are very popular for fire protection systems. They are reliable, durable, and strong. More importantly, they offer excellent strength and resistance to high temperatures.
What Are Steel Pipes?
Steel pipes are made of iron and a small amount of carbon (usually 0.08 — 0.6%). Manufacturers roll the flat steel and turn it into a tube shape to produce these types of pipes. These steels are light and easier to join by welding.
As you may know, steel can rust very fast, especially in more humid regions. That is why steel pipes usually require a protective coating and may not be suitable for any condition.
Types of Steel Pipes
There are two main types of steel pipes in the market:
- carbon steel pipe (uncoated)
- galvanized steel pipe (zinc-coated)
Carbon steel pipes are made by rolling or welding steel sheets into tubes. They don’t have a zinc coating; it means they can rust more easily than the other types. If you want to use them, it is better to apply them to short-term projects or indoor plumbing, where corrosion is less likely. You can also apply additional protective coatings for greater resistance.
On the other hand, Galvanized steel pipes provide a strong, durable, cost-effective, and corrosion-resistant piping system. Galvanized steel pipes have many uses because they are widely available.
Advantages of Using Steel Pipes
- Easy to Find: Steel pipes are available wherever you look. Steel is one of the most widely used materials for pipe production worldwide.
- Very Strong: They can handle heavy loads and high pressure. They don’t actually break easily.
- Cost-Effective: Steel pipes are usually less expensive to buy at the beginning of the project, but other types may be more expensive.
- Easy to Handle and Install: steel pipes are light, simple to cut, and quick to join. So, you don’t have to spend a lot of time on installation.
Common Applications for Steel Pipes
- Construction: Contractors and engineers use steel pipes for building supports, scaffolding, frames, handrails, and other structures.
- Oil and Gas Lines: They are really useful for transferring oil, gas, and other fluids under high pressure and over long distances.
- Industrial Systems: You can see steel pipes in factories and plants used to move liquids or gases safely under high pressure.
- Short-Term Water Lines: A good pick for indoor pipes or temporary water systems, especially where rust isn’t a big concern.
Metallurgical & Structural Comparison
When we look at both pipes at a microscopic level, they are built very differently. That is why each pipe comes with unique features. Here’s a clear comparison table:
| Property | Ductile Iron | Steel (Carbon / Galvanized) |
|---|---|---|
| Carbon Content | 3.0–3.9% | 0.08–0.6% |
| Graphite Form | Spheroidal nodules (tiny round balls) | None |
| Damping Capacity | High | Low |
| Manufacturing | Cast (molten metal poured into molds) | Rolled/Welded |
| Density | Heavier | Lighter |
Note: According to ResearchGate, the round graphite nodules in ductile iron are responsible for this large difference. You ask how? Have a look at the items below:
Self-lubrication: They release small amounts of graphite that act like natural oil. It reduces friction and wear in the pipe to a minimum.
Damping: Shakes and vibrations have no effect on the pipe, so the pipe remains strong when the ground moves.
Crack resistance: If a crack starts, the round nodules stop it from growing fast.
Mechanical Strengths
Ductile Iron Pipe: Ductile iron has higher yield strength, so it does not get deformed or break easily under high pressure. That is why ductile iron pipes are great for underground use.
Steel Pipe: Steel is more flexible (stretches more) and much easier to weld. So it is much better for custom shapes or areas with ground movement.
| Property | Ductile Iron Pipe | Steel Pipe |
|---|---|---|
| Tensile Strength | 60,000 psi | 60,000 – 70,000 psi |
| Yield Strength | 40,000 – 45,000 psi | 36,000 psi |
| Elongation | 10–18% | 20–24% |
| Modulus of Elasticity | 24 × 10⁶ psi | 30 × 10⁶ psi |
Corrosion & Abrasion Resistance
- Ductile Iron Pipe: They don’t rust easily due to their natural graphite. The protective coatings (made from bitumen, epoxy, or PE sleeves) make it a long-lasting pipe even under the harshest conditions. The hard surface of the pipe makes it resistant to sand, gravel, or thick sludge. It does not wear down easily.
- Steel Pipe: Galvanized type uses zinc that rusts before the steel, protecting the steel. It shows good protection at the beginning. However, once the zinc is gone, steel rusts quickly. Carbon steel rusts quickly without any coating. It has a softer surface that wears faster from gritty or sandy water. You can expect slight wear and tear inside over time.
Hydraulic Performance
- Ductile Iron Pipe: The pipe is lined with a cement-mortar lining that keeps the inside wall smooth. As noted on the Engineering Too Box, the Hazen-Williams C-factor sits at 130–140 (the higher the number, the smoother the flow). You will see the pipe keeping this feature even for decades. That causes a 20–40% reduction in electricity for pumping.
- Steel Pipe: Steel pipes also have a cement-mortar. The Hazen-Williams C-factor is 120–130. The smoothness is good at the beginning, but it can turn rougher over time. That leads to greater pressure loss and higher long-term pumping costs.
Installation & Handling
- Ductile Iron: The push-on joints in ductile iron pipes make them extremely easy to install; no welding is needed. These pipes are heavier, but you can assemble them more quickly. You can easily cut or tap them right on the job site.
- Steel: Steel pipes require welded joints during installation, so they take more time, tools, and skilled workers. Pipes are light and easy to lift. However, shorter lengths mean more joints. Many changes on-site need welding, too.
Let’s have a look at this quick comparison table:
</tr class=”active-row”>
| Aspect | Ductile Iron Pipe | Steel Pipe |
|---|---|---|
| Joint Type | Push-on (rubber gasket, quick) | Welded (time-consuming) |
| Weight | Heavier | Lighter |
| Segment Length | Longer (fewer joints) | Shorter (more joints) |
| Field Modifications | Easy cutting and tapping | Needs welding |
| Installation Speed | Faster for most projects | Slower due to welding |
Diameter & Application
- Ductile Iron Pipe: These pipes are definitely the top pick for diameters under 600 mm. Push-on joints mean you will require no welding, the pipes are long, and you need fewer joints. Handling stays manageable for typical water and sewer projects.
- Steel Pipe: We consider steel pipes more applicable for diameters of 600 mm or greater. Transporting these pipes is much easier because they are lighter. So, it may become less important that they require many welding joints.
Here is a quick comparison of where ductile iron pipe and steel pipe (galvanized or carbon) work best:
| Use Case | Ductile Iron Pipe | Steel Pipe (Galvanized & Carbon) |
|---|---|---|
| Water Supply | Top choice for long-term mains; great corrosion resistance and 100+ year life | Good for short-term or indoor use; rust risk over time |
| Sewage Systems | Best for corrosive wastewater; reliable with coatings | Works with extra protection; corrodes faster |
| Fire Protection | Popular for high strength and pressure reliability | Solid option, especially indoors or above ground |
| Industrial Systems | Strong for high-pressure fluids and slurries | Common for oil/gas; lighter and easy to weld |
| Above-Ground Installations | Works with supports | Preferred; lighter weight and simpler fabrication |
Durability & Maintenance
- Ductile Iron Pipe: These pipes are able to work 80 to 100 years or even longer in normal conditions. They also require the least maintenance because they are already corrosion-resistant. The only thing you need to do is check them once in a while. Keep an eye on soil pH and humidity levels, and maintain careful coating upkeep to keep the pipes for years.
- Steel Pipe: These pipes typically have a life expectancy of 40 to 60 years, not much compared to iron. They are in danger of corrosion even with the Zinc coating. Carbon steel corrodes even more quickly. So, if you want to keep them longer, you must not forget the regular checks.
Cost & Lifecycle
- Ductile Iron Pipe: They are expensive and do not seem cost-effective at first. However, they cost you much less in the long run. You should consider all costs together, such as the installation, maintenance, and energy consumption. Besides, ductile iron pipes last for decades, so you do not need to replace them.
- Steel Pipe: You spend less on a steel pipe purchase. But do not forget the higher costs for installation, maintenance, and energy consumption. Their shorter life span is also a problem that may cause trouble in the long run.
Look at the table below to understand the differences much better:
| Cost Category | Ductile Iron Pipe | Steel Pipe (Galvanized & Carbon) |
|---|---|---|
| Material Cost | Moderate to higher | Lower |
| Installation Cost | Lower (fast push-on joints) | Higher (welding time and labour) |
| Maintenance Cost | Low (fewer repairs over decades) | Higher (more checks and fixes) |
| Energy Cost (pumping) | Lower (smooth flow lasts longer) | Higher (flow gets rougher over time) |
| Total Lifecycle Cost | Lower overall | Higher overall |
Environmental & Sustainability
- Ductile Iron Pipe: Manufacturers produce ductile iron pipe using 95% recycled scrap (source: DIPRA). These pipes are a genuine respect for the environment and save a lot of energy with the least mining. They are 100% recyclable. There won’t be any waste, and this is also beneficial economically.
- Steel Pipe: Plain carbon steel is easily recycled. But galvanized steel has a zinc coating. When it’s time to recycle, people must handle the zinc carefully to avoid harming the environment. This makes the process more complicated and expensive.
The Main Differences at a Glance
The following table sums up the main differences between ductile iron pipes and steel pipes. It makes it easy to see which one fits most projects better.
| Property | Ductile Iron Pipe | Steel Pipe (Galvanized & Carbon) | Better for Most Projects |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tensile Strength | 60,000 psi (minimum) | 60,000–70,000 psi | About the same |
| Yield Strength | 42,000 psi (minimum) | Around 36,000 psi | Ductile Iron |
| Flexibility (Elongation) | 10–18% | 20–24% | Steel |
| Lifespan | 100+ years | 40–60 years | Ductile Iron |
| Corrosion Resistance | Very good – natural protection plus strong coatings | Good at first, but zinc coating wears off | Ductile Iron |
| Abrasion Resistance | High – handles sand and gravel well | Lower – wears faster | Ductile Iron |
| Water Flow (Hazen-Williams C-factor) | 130–140 – stays smooth for many years | 120–130 – gets rougher over time | Ductile Iron |
| Installation | Faster – simple push-on joints, no welding needed | Slower – needs welding and more skill | Ductile Iron |
| Total Cost Over Time | Lower – less maintenance and lower pumping costs | Higher – more repairs and energy use | Ductile Iron |
| Environmental Impact | 90–98% recycled material; easy to recycle again | Good for plain steel; zinc makes recycling harder | Ductile Iron |
What Are the Advantages of Ductile Iron Pipes Provided by Yasmin Trading?
Many engineers and contractors in the UAE and GCC pick ductile iron pipes for water, sewage, fire protection, and industrial projects. Yasmin Trading has long been a trusted supplier of ductile iron pipe in this region, partnering with various successful projects. Below, we will explain why the ductile iron pipes that we provide can be your top choice:
Technical Benefits
The ductile iron pipes we supply stand out for their technical and performance characteristics. Have a look at the following list to understand why:
- They handle high pressure, heavy loads, and ground shifts easily. Their special internal structure stops cracks.
- They resist rust very well. Natural protection and coatings keep corrosion away for longer.
- They last 80–100+ years. You need very little maintenance.
- They save money over time. The initial cost may match or beat steel, but quick installation, lower energy for pumping, and fewer repairs cut long-term expenses.
- They keep water flowing smoothly. The inside lining stays smooth for decades, saving energy on pumping.
- You install them quickly and simply, thanks to the easy-to-use push-on joints.
Advantages for Your Business
In addition to the exceptional quality of our iron pipes, we provide you with extra value for your business, including:
- We always have a full range of standard sizes in stock, ready to ship without delays.
- We customize coatings (bitumen, epoxy, or polyethylene sleeves)according to your project to protect pipes exactly the way you need.
- You get peace of mind with pipes that meet all global standards, plus our team offers clear, expert advice from start to finish.
- No matter where you are, we deliver quick and reliable service across the UAE and every GCC country.
Yasmin Trading: The Leading Ductile Pipe Supplier in UAE and GCC
Here you are, looking for a reliable ductile iron pipe supplier in the UAE and across the whole GCC, and Yasmin Trading is here for you. Years of experience and vast expertise help us stay at the top of the list for countless projects, including municipal water supply, sewage and wastewater systems, fire protection networks, gas distribution, and industrial pipelines. Feel free to contact us at info@yasmintrading.com and ask for the information you need.
Frequently Asked Questions
- How long does a ductile iron pipe last compared to a steel pipe?
Ductile iron can last even more than 100 years. On the other hand, steel pipes last 40 to 60 years.
- Which pipe resists corrosion better, ductile iron or steel?
Ductile iron resists corrosion better. It has natural protection and strong coatings. Galvanized steel protects well at first, but it starts to rust once the zinc coating fades.
- What are the differences in installation between ductile iron and steel pipes?
Ductile iron is much easier and faster to install. It uses simple push-on joints. Steel pipes need welding, skilled workers, and more time.
- Which pipe costs less in the long run, ductile iron or steel?
Steel pipes seem cost-effective at the beginning, but ductile iron costs less over time. It needs little maintenance, saves on pumping energy, and lasts much longer.
Leave a Reply