Scissor Lift Vs. Boom Lift: How to Choose the Right Aerial Platform for Your Project?

One of the trendiest discussions among engineers is the comparison between scissor lifts vs boom lifts. These aerial platforms can help you when working above ground level on a construction project. While boom lifts can move in vertical and horizontal directions, scissor work platforms only offer vertical movements. It is the most significant difference between these two elevated work platforms. Hydraulic, rough terrain, diesel, electric, and pneumatic scissor lifts are available for different needs. On the other hand, boom lifts are categorized as articulating, telescopic, and bucket truck devices. You need to consider factors like height, capacity, budget, and range of motion for your project to see which aerial lift can meet your needs. Keep reading this blog to learn the main differences between boom lifts and scissor lifts.

What Is a Scissor Lift?

According to the experts of BigRentz, the scissor lift is a practical machine with a large aerial work platform. It moves vertically and is professionally supported by crisscrossed braces. That is why engineers prefer using a scissor lift compared to other aerial platforms, which elevates multiple workers. The good thing about this equipment is that it can stay firmly on the ground, decreasing the risk of unexpected workplace incidents. There are hydraulic, pneumatic, and mechanical scissor lifts available to choose based on specific needs. Here, we go deeper and assess the pros, cons, different types, and applications of scissor lifts.

Pros

There are some unique features that make a scissor lift distinct from other heavy platforms.

Various Height and Capacity: Scissor lifts come in many different heights and capacities, making them eligible for outdoor or indoor projects.

Large Platform: The platform of this aerial lift is large enough to move workers and equipment at the same time.
Efficiency: The electrical type of scissor lifts are eco-friendly and energy-efficient.
Stability: The scissor-like design makes this machine stable enough in the toughest conditions.
Safety: These devices offer enough protection for operators when moving upwards.

Cons

On the other hand, scissor lifts are limited in some aspects.

Limited Maneuver: They are not as maneuverable as other lifting devices.
Limited Access: Scissor machines can only lift up to about 60 feet vertically. This reach limitation can make them inefficient in some cases.
Positioning: Professionals need to place this elevated work platform near the work area. Otherwise, it can not offer the best performance.

Different Types

Generally, there are five popular varieties of scissor lifts. Experts choose each one based on their project requirements.

Hydraulic: It uses an engine-driven hydraulic system as the power source. It is offered in various models with high lifting power and reach abilities.
Rough Terrain: The power source is a diesel engine. It has reinforced tires and is 4WD and a good option for slopes and mud.
Diesel: As it is obvious, it works with a diesel engine. It is equipped with high horsepower. Also, it can traverse slopes and uneven terrain.
Electric: It is powered by a battery and is offered in a compact size, with minimum noise possible and zero emissions.
Pneumatic: It works with air pressure and requires less maintenance.

Applications

The applications of scissor lift devices are explained here.

Maintenance: These aerial lifts can be used to repair and maintain different parts of buildings.
Manufacturing: It gives expert access to high areas of the production floor.
Transportation: They are used to repair and maintain huge transportation means such as aircraft, trains, and buses.
Construction: The benefits and applications of a scissor lift are significantly important in construction projects.
Retail: Business owners use these vertical lifts to manage and organize products in high-shelving units.

What Is a Boom Lift?

A boom lift has a compact elevating work platform to move workers or equipment pieces. It is supported by a hydraulic arm and a grounded base for optimal function. Professionals use these platforms outdoor or indoor based on the project requirements. Telescopic and articulating platforms are two common types of boom lifts that should be chosen according to specific demands.

Pros

There are some specific advantages that make boom lifts superior.

Versatility: Their articulating arms can move in different directions and reach even the most challenging areas without any problems. Also, their 4WD and tight turning radius options make them highly maneuverable around obstacles.
Portability: Boom lifts can be easily placed on trucks or trailers to transport into other locations.
Stability: Boom lifts offer a secure platform to move workers in different directions.

Cons

While boom lifts offer amazing benefits, there are some cons to know before making any decisions.

Cost: They require a higher budget, and you need to consider it as an investment.
Complex Setup: The setup process of boom lifts requires more time, energy, and expertise.

Different Types

There are three primary types of boom lifts: articulating, telescopic, and bucket trucks.

Articulating: It may work with diesel, electric, or battery power sources. It is versatile in different spaces due to its Hinged section.
Telescopic: It has a diesel power source that is widely used in outdoor projects and has a straight arm for high accessibility.
Bucket Trucks: Bucket trucks are equipped with diesel, electric, or LPG sources and provide engineers with dielectric isolation.

Applications

The applications of boom lift devices are explained here.

Material Lifting: Boom lifts are suitable for transporting heavy items and materials during projects.
Film Production: Although it may be surprising, boom aerial platforms can help cameramen take shots from high locations.
Construction: The most common applications of this elevated work platform is in construction projects. They offer access to unreachable areas and are used to maintain or repair skyscrapers.

What Are the Key Differences Between Boom and Scissor Lifts?

These two popular cherry pickers are different from each other in some critical factors. Keep reading this table to know more about these differences.

Factor	Boom Lifts	Scissor Lifts
Design	Hydraulic arm with a small platform	Larger platform on support beams
Motion Range	Vertical and horizontal	Vertical only
Size	Smaller	Larger
Accessibility	Maximum 210 ft	Maximum 60 ft
Capacity	Maximum 1000 lbs	Maximum 1500 lbs
Location	Indoor and outdoor	Indoor and outdoor
Cost	More expensive	More budget-friendly

How to Choose the Right Aerial Lift?

Boom and scissor lifts both provide access to inaccessible aerial job areas. Yet, they are different in some ways, and you need to make your decision to understand these differences. As JLG professionals discussed, there are some factors to consider to make your choice wisely.

Height

Typically, boom lifts reach higher areas, and that is why they are used to reach roofs and billboards. On the other hand, scissor lifts are used inside buildings or small warehouses since they can only extend up to 43 feet.

Budget

As you know, boom lifts have a more complex design and also offer more technical benefits. If your budget is limited and your project is not that complicated, a scissor lift is a good option. However, you should go for a boom lift if you are dealing with significant undertakings and want to solve challenges successfully.

Direction

Scissor lifts only move vertically, while boom aerial platforms can move both vertically and horizontally. If your project requires movements to harder-to-reach areas, a boom lift is a wise decision. But if you only demand moving up and down, hiring or purchasing a scissor lift can meet your needs.

Capacity

Boom lifts provide you with a higher level of maneuverability, but their platforms are smaller. If you demand moving multiple workers with their equipment, a scissor lift can meet your requirements.

Generally speaking, you need to answer two critical questions before making your final choice.

Which direction do you want to move?
How high do you need to go?

Once you find the answers to these questions, you can choose the suitable machine for your project.

Why Should You Choose Yasmin Trading?

Our experts are here to accompany you on this long journey. We have the expertise and experience needed to help you choose the best aerial lift based on your needs and overall condition. If you are looking for a trusted partner for top-grade equipment, you can rely on our specialists. Don’t hesitate to consult our professionals as soon as possible!

Sources:

Scissor Lift Vs. Boom Lift: How to Choose the Right Aerial Platform for Your Project?